|
Final List Seminars: Perspectives on September 11
Honors Collegium 98
Fall Quarter 2001
Understanding the Taliban
John Agnew; Geography
What is the Taliban? What is their political and military position in Afghanistan? How does
Afghanistan fit into the larger framework of Central and South West Asian politics? What is
the relationship between the Taliban and terrorist groups?
Understanding the Unthinkable and Incomprehensible
Edward A. Alpers; History
In this course we will try to understand two fundamental questions that are raised by events of
September 11. First, how can people unleash acts of terror on innocent citizens? Second, what are
the consequences of mutual cultural ignorance? To help us reach our goals, we will read about two
very different situations that address each of these questions by itself and may provide a methodology
for comprehending our current predicament.
Honor & Shame and the Clash of Civilizations
S. Scott Bartchy; History
Honor and shame are core values in most cultures of the world, including many in which Islam
is the majority religion. Not understanding this fact has led to serious misunderstandings
and misjudgments in the foreign policies of the USA. In this seminar we will examine these
values and the social codes which provide the doorway to an in-depth understanding of male
and female socialization and behavior. Comprehensive comparisons will be made with the social
codes resulting from "western" values of individual achievement and guilt.Professor
Bartchy is Director of the Center for the Study of Religion.
The Struggle to Understand, the Struggle to Respond
C. Adolfo Bermeo; Cesar Chavez Center
Using film and readings, the events of September 11 will be examined in the historical context of U.S.
foreign policy, the relationships between the developed and underdeveloped worlds, the rise of political
Islam, and the use and nature of terrorism since WWII. Students will consider possible U.S.
responses to the events of September 11 and defend what the U.S. should do and why.
Bin Laden and Terrorism outside the U.S.: The Case of Uzbekistan
Andras J.E Bodrogligeti; Near Eastern Languages and Cultures
In the post-Soviet period there was an attempt to establish an Islamic Republic in Uzbekistan.
Islam Karimov's resistance in the Namangan meeting of radical Muslims. On February 16 a group
of Bin Laden's agents carried out a concentrated attempt to kill President Karimov. What were
the conspirators' objectives? What measures did the Uzbek government take toward the danger of
Asama Bin Laden efforts? Were the Wahhabites involved in the plot? Prospectives for
the immediate future?
Navigating Between Blithesome Optimism and Cultural Despair
Albert Boime; Art History
I intend to share the sense of crisis about my teaching mission that I experienced on September 11, and
examine the context of Enlightenment values that have given meaning to my life's work. My faith
in the unlimited creativity of human beings in solving the problems of their environment, in the capacity
of the imagination to invent new solutions to economic, physical and psychological dilemmas, in the liberation
of mental energy and fresh ideas from the fetters of dogma and fear, was sorely tested on that fateful
Tuesday. I will attempt to dissect and comprehend the events through their representations, for only
through understanding can we prevent future recurrences of such events.
Information Technology and Infrastructure in Times of Crisis
Christine L. Borgman; Information Studies
Computer networks (e.g., the Internet) and telecommunications are part of an infrastructure that
underlies the nation’s – and the world’s – financial, transportation, power, water, emergency
services, and communications frameworks. The vulnerability of that interconnected
infrastructure was never more evident than on September 11, 2001. Yet the information
infrastructure also enabled people to locate each other, to maintain contact, and to get
information in a time of crisis. In this seminar we will address questions such as,
What is an information infrastructure? What role does information infrastructure play
in people’s lives? How can information technology be used to improve communications and access
to information in times of crisis? What are the threats to civil liberties (e.g.,
privacy, freedom of speech, freedom of access to information) associated with technology-based
information infrastructures? How can we advance global communications networks, in
light of their use for good and for evil?
Making Sense of the New World Disorder
Rogers Brubaker; Sociology
Democracy, in principle, requires well-informed citizens. This is no small challenge.
With all of cyberspace at our fingertips, not to speak of the broadcast and print media, we are
awash in information: but are we well informed? The horrific events of September 11
and their aftermath raise this question with special urgency. In this seminar, we will
discuss what ordinary citizens can do to make intelligent critical use of the media -- and of
web-based resources in particular to inform themselves about the events, their contexts, and their
sequels.
Fictions of Terror vs. Real Terror
Frederick Burwick; English
In arguments about the pretensions of realist drama in the 18th century, it was said that if a real
execution was taking place in the town square, the population would go there rather than watch a
pretend execution in the theater. Does the population have a morbid curiosity to watch real gore and
slaughter? What is the purpose of violence in film, drama, and literature? Since the frequency and
extent of terror and violence in the arts is not a constant, presumably the degree of morbid fascination
is related to social events. This seminar will discuss fictive terror as a phenomenon in the popular
media in relation to incidents of actual terror.
National Security in the 21st Century
Albert Carnesale; Policy Studies
During the Cold War, Americans saw the Soviet Union's nuclear arsenal as the primary threat
to U.S. security. With the collapse of the Soviet empire, and in the wake of catastrophic
terrorist attacks on U.S. soil, two fundamental questions arise: (1) what are the near-term
threats to the security of the U.S. and other nations?; and (2) how might those threats best
be met?
War, Terror and Violence: Reflecting on Machiavelli
Brian Copenhaver; History and Philosophy
Is war a legitimate instrument of politics? Can war be a just act of the state?
How do wars waged by states differ from acts of violence by individuals? Why is
the word 'terror' used for some acts of violence? This seminar will explore these
questions from the point of view expressed by Niccolo Machiavelli in parts of
The Prince, a book written almost five centuries ago but often cited today when
such questions are discussed.
What Do We Tell the Children?: Parenting Issues
Chandice Covington; Nursing
Children look to parents for cues to cope with stressful events. The events of September 11
have placed parents in the situation of explaining and reassuring their children. In this
course, through guest speakers, discussion, and readings on "best practices," students will
address parental issues and approaches to the tragic events directed to the promotion of child and family
health.
Implications of World Crises for Student Stress and Academic Achievement: Coping Strategies
Winston Doby; Higher Education
Exploration of the relationship among world crises, students stress as they relate to student
achievement. Students will maintain a journal during the quarter, including interviews
of other students. Enrollment limited.
Historical Perspectives on September 11
Ellen DuBois; History and Joyce Appleby; History
This course will have two tasks. First we will do our best to set the events
of and claims about September 11 in historical perspective. Second, we will examine
critically the historical claims being made by politicians in the media, to see how history is
being used at this critical moment.
Stress and Coping in the Aftermath of a National Disaster
Chris Dunkel Schetter; Psychology - Social
This seminar will explore stress and coping responses that occurred following the major disaster
including post traumatic stress disorder. We will read brief selections from the
literature on responses to major disasters and we will collect and evaluate articles on media
coverage of stress and coping following the terrorist attacks. Videos may be utilized.
Personal experiences will be shared. Community responses will be explored. In
short, we will consider the nature of this stress and the variety of responses that have occurred
using a critical analysis of what is adaptive and what may not be.
Culture and the Deferral of Violence
Eric Gans; French and Francophone Studies
Exploration of the hypothesis that human language and culture is essentially a means of
deferring violence, and its application to the current situation.
America as Hyperpower
Geoffrey Garrett; Political Science
The US today is far more powerful than it was during the cold war,
arguably more powerful than any country in history. There are many dimensions
to America's global dominance: commerce, politics, security, media and
entertainment. People in the US, on the street and in Washington, believe that
American power has been used benevolently, for the good of all the world. But
reactions tend to be very different outside America, running the gamut from
polite disgruntlement to mass protests, and finally to the tragic events of
September 11. How has the US used its power since the end of the cold war? Why
have many in the rest of the world reacted negatively to this? How should the US
act in the coming years?
An 'East' and a 'West'? Thinking about the 'Clash of Civilizations'
James L. Gelvin; History
The purpose of this seminar is to examine recent writings about the 'clash of
civilizations,' written by both Anglophone and Middle Eastern scholars, to put
them into their historical context, and appraise their validity for understanding
history and contemporary events.
Beyond Tears: Evidence, Fact, and Crisis
Kenneth Graham; Law
An exploration of the evidentiary concepts that may help students and citizens
avoid being misled by those who manipulate crisis for their own ends.
Recognizing and Dealing with Stress during a Time of Crisis
Carlos Grijalva; Psychology - Behavioral
There is no doubt that the tragic events of September 11 impact us all in ways that can affect
our mental and physical well being. The purpose of this seminar is to gain a better
understanding of "stress" both from a psychological and physiological perspective, and
to explore ways to cope with and reduce the impact of stressful events.
The Search for Identity? Insurgent Islam and the Response of the West--the Sudanese Case
Sondra Hale, Anthropology; Gerry Hale, Geography
September 11 raises questions of how we think about the interconnections among religion
(Islam), global economics, culture, terror, war, and ourselves. Problematic
relationships between the U.S. and an Islamist regime in Sudan form a perplexing case
involving issues of ethnic and religious identity, economic development, regionalism,
human rights, and the use of violence.
Psychological Perspectives: Anxiety, Stress, and Depression
Constance Hammen; Psychology - Clinical
Faculty and graduate students in clinical psychology will lead discussions on what we
know about emotional reactions to trauma and stress, and how they may be treated in
individuals, families, and couples. Topics may include normal and abnormal
fear and anxiety; post traumatic stress disorder; depression; reactions to stress; children's
responses to fear and trauma; treatments--including therapy, disaster debriefing, crisis
intervention, community interventions.
The Map of Love an Exploration of Islam and the Colonial Experience through a
Novel by Egyptian Writer Adhaf Soueif
Katherine Callen King; Comparative Literature
We will explore and explode popular misconceptions about the quality of Islamic culture in Egypt,
including the status of women and the effect of British imperialism and the stereotypes it sought
and found. We will look at violence and discuss whether the novel presents it as inevitable or
as preventable. We will read a few chapters every week and discuss these issues and other
relevant ones as they come up.
Terrorism and the Politics of Knowledge
Vinay Lal; History
While the world rightfully stands united in its condemnation of the bombings of September 11,
the American mainstream media has remained impervious to those critical voices which have also
drawn attention to America's own record of imperialistic adventurism and the relation
of the WTC bombings to American excesses in Iraq, Sudan, and the Middle East. This
seminar asks fundamental questions about how we constitute "terrorism" and its
agents. What are the categories of knowledge deployed to understand "terror"?
Should the continuing sanctions against Iraq also be considered a form of terrorism?
What is the relationship of the bin Ladens of this world to "Western state
terrorism"? Who defines and names terrorism, with what authority, and with what
consequences?
War and Autobiography: Testimonials from Algeria and the Belgian Congo
Francoise Lionnet; French and Francophone Studies
Selections from two novels dealing with the aftermath of the Algerian War of
Independence, and one film dealing with the Belgian Congo. The focus will be
on the expressions of despair, mourning, and melancholia in these autobiographical
narratives.
Women's Participation in Political Violence
Judith Magee; History
The course poses the question: What is women's relationship to political violence?
Using a feminist lens, the course examines the participation of women in radical political
movements in the late twentieth-century United States. Women are often not the
director actors in violent acts; more often they are victims, participants, or accomplices.
The course tries to understand the motivations, complex behaviors, and worldviews of radical women.
Understanding, Respecting and Honoring the First Amendment in a Terrorist Environment
Joe Mandel; Law
We will examine judicial opinions and supplementary materials that address
interpretations and applications of the First Amendment to the United Sates
Constitution in the context of the country's most politically charged and
turbulent times. This will include events that followed the passage of the
Sedition Act of 1798, World War I, the 1920's "Red Scare," World War
II, the "Cold War," the Vietnam War. We will explore this fundamental
provision of the Bill of Rights, the ideal of free speech and various constraints
and pressures on that ideal. We will also explore how the judicial system has sought
to define the outer limits of the protections the First Amendment provides in the
context of various challenges to the American way of life.
Concepts of the Terror in Western Culture from the French Revolution to the Present
Robert M. Maniquis; English
Religious, political, and literary aspects of terror in its modern Western contexts.
First session, one hour, thereafter every other Thursday evening for two hours. Email
instructor for place and time.
September 11th: Reflections on Terrorism, its Origins and Consequences
Jose C. Moya; History
We will examine the nature of present-day terrorism, its historical roots, the Middle-East and
the role of the U.S. in the region, and the impact of September 11th on domestic and international
politics.
Terror and Its Psychological Impact
Alan Nagamoto; Psychology
The unprecedented acts of terror will likely leave indelible images in our memories. In the wake
of these shocking attacks and amidst rumors of additional attacks, there arises a unique opportunity
for us to learn firsthand about psychological trauma and its many levels of impact. This course will
cover what is known about psychological trauma and also explore how this particular tragedy might
impact us as a nation as well as individually. Students will be encouraged to deepen awareness of
the psychological effects of this tragedy as well as to articulate what new meaning can be found
through these tragic experiences.
The World Conference against Racism: Illusions, Collusions, and/or Opportunities
William D. Parham; Psychology
Thousands of participants, including world leaders and caucus groups representing populations
from around the globe, attended the World Conference Against Racism, Racial Discrimination,
Xenophobia and Related Intolerance (WCAR) that convened in Durban, South Africa, August 29 -
September 8, 2001. Answers to questions regarding the "real" outcome of the conference
vary depending on the respondents being queried. Factors contributing to the successes and failures
of the WCAR will be identified and the implications for said outcomes will be examined. Course
participants will then be invited to review post-Durban recommendations for change and
subsequently encouraged to think about ways of translating said or course generated
recommendations into concrete programs for our campus and our home communities.
Silence, Slogans, and Flags
Carol Petersen; Writing Programs
Along with moments of silence have come new slogans (“Attack on America”), new images (the changed
New York skyline), and renewed patriotism (a flag raised, as in Iwo Jima, over a site of death and
rubble). We’ll consider the role of language, images, symbols, and symbolic acts in dealing with
September 11.
Law and the Use of Force
Kal Raustiala; Law
This seminar will examine both the international and constitutional law governing the use of military
force. The resort to force is a core attribute of the international system, but one that is increasingly
bound by legal rules that govern how and when force may be used. At the domestic level, the US
Constitution allocates power among the branches of government with regard to the use of force. One
manifestation of that allocation was the Congressional resolution authorizing the President to use
"all necessary and appropriate force." We will consider what role these various legal rules
can, and should, play in influencing any military reaction to the September 11 attack.
Terror and the Dilemmas of American Power
Geoffrey Robinson - History; Jessica Wang - History
Why did the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11 occur? How can the U.S. respond, without
endangering liberties within the United States or making itself a pariah in the international
community? We will explore these questions from historical and contemporary vantage
points, by considering the nature of U.S. foreign relations, attitudes of the Islamic world
toward the United States, and American concerns with internal security throughout the 20th
century.
Biological and Chemical Weapons: Assessing the Terrorist Threat.
Ralph Robinson; Microbiology and Molecular Genetics
In the weeks following the Sept. 11 attacks, fears have increased concerning the release of
biological or chemical weapons (BCW). We will examine the types of agents that terrorist
groups would most likely try to use. A historical review of BCW use by armies and terrorist
groups will demonstrate how effective these weapons can be. The medical aspects of transmission,
symptoms, treatment, and prevention will be discussed in lay person’s terms. Finally, we will
examine the defensive measures being developed that will hopefully prevent terrorists from
successfully deploying these types of weapons.
The Terror of History: A Search for Justice
Teofilo F. Ruiz; History
This course will explore the rise of violence and radical movements in the Western tradition, and the ambiguities that we
have faced historically between combating these movements and creating a world which is just and peaceful.
Responses to National and Personal Tragedies in the Bible (Prophets and Psalms)
Yona Sabar; Near Eastern Languages and Cultures
Selected texts of the prophets and the poets of the Bible.How do they reconcile their feelings of despair with their
trust in God after an incomprehensible catastrophe? Which metaphors and other linguistic means do they use
to express their visions for a better future and recovery? Knowledge of Hebrew preferred but not required.
Justice and War: The Ethics of International Conflicts
Andrew Sabl; Policy Studies
War involves organized, deliberate killing. In spite of that, some wars are called "just" if they
are fought for legitimate reasons, keep open the possibility of peace, and show proper respect for
the rights of prisoners and noncombatants. This seminar will explore and debate the idea of just
wars through short readings in ethics (historical and contemporary) and real-world cases.
Privilege, Power, and Difference: Is Tolerance Enough?
Ronni Sanlo; Education
This seminar explores thoughts, identities, and ideas about privilege and power, the differences with
which each student comes to the campus community, and the difference each student can make.
Literature as Mourning: China and Greece
David Schaberg; East Asian Languages and Cultures
Examines texts from world literature, especially the Chinese and Greek traditions, as responses to the
loss of loved ones and as ways of managing, cultivating, and redirecting the force of grief.
“Black Hawk Down: A Story of Modern War”
Craig Smith; Medicine
The U.S. Special Forces will be on the front lines of the new war against terrorism. In order to
understand these forces, this course will focus on “Black Hawk Down: A Story of Modern War” by
investigative journalist Mark Bowden. This book provides a strikingly detailed account of the 1993
nightmare operation in Mogadishu that left 18 American soldiers dead and many more wounded. Dr.
Smith serves as a general surgeon in the U.S. Army Reserve Medical Corps.
What the U.S. Should Do to Be Popular in the Third World
Earl Thompson; Economics
The reasons for the unpopularity of the U.S. government in the third world are examined. The
persistently negative reaction of the Latin American left wing against U.S. trade policies; the
20th century condemnations of the U.S. by essentially all communist countries; the "Ugly American"
in Southeast Asia, the demonstrations against our WTO meetings; and the growing Arab hatred of
the U.S.: Are these hatreds coincidental? What do they have in common? Although our policy
makers clearly desire to help these countries, have we subconsciously evolved policies that are
highly economically inefficient and essentially exploitative of the third world?
International English-Language Newspaper Coverage
Dominic Thomas; French and Francophone Studies
The events of September 11, 2001 have generated a plethora of stimulating debates in the international
English-language media. The focus of the seminar will be provided by a consideration of these
responses, reflection on perceptions of American foreign policy, the exploration of anti-American sentiment,
and assiduous monitoring of emerging discussions.
Echoes of Terror in Brain, Mind, and Literature
Allan Tobin, Medicine; Janet Hadda, English
Traumatic historical events, such as those of September 11, evoke both shared and highly individual responses.
In this seminar, we will discuss ways in which people cope with public terror in their lives. We will examine
the neurobiological and psychological effects of terror and the transformation of these responses into creative
expression.
The Role of Art and Technology in Times of War
Victoria Vesna; Design
What is the role and responsibility of writers, artists, architects, designers, musicians and other creative practitioners in
these extraordinary times? In this seminar we will begin with a short overview of mainstream and alternative culture
in the US during times of war. Then we will look at how creative use of technology can be employed to preserve our freedom
of speech, promote difference and tolerance and create spaces for audiences to voice their opinions and share their feelings during
times of conflict.
Perspectives on War and Terror thereto--through Theatre, Art and Music
Wm. Tom Wheatley; Theater
Through the reading of plays, the listening to selected music, and the viewing of art, students will
find parallels (through the ages) to our current crisis. Students will discuss these and
report on one or two.
Poetry and Loss
Reed Wilson; English
It might be said that the art of poetry is often an art that consoles and challenges us through great
feelings of loss. In this course we will read selections from a number of contemporary poets,
as well as write and share our own poems on subjects of loss. No special experience with reading
or writing poetry is expected, just the willingness to explore one of the many ways women and men have come
to terms with the need to remember, to grieve, and to heal.
Psychology of Group Identity
Victor Wolfenstein; Political Science
Enrollment restricted to students in Political Science 113.
At War with the Afghans and Chechens: The Russian Experience
Olga T. Yokoyama; Slavic Languages and Literature
What is the experience of Russians in their recent war in Afghanistan? What are their fears,
prejudices, and sympathies towards the Chechens, whom they have been fighting for several years
now? How does Russian literature and film view the culture of Islam? The seminar
will examine such questions through the literature and film of a non-Islamic neighbor that has had
Muslims within and around its borders since the Middle Ages, and which provide a fascinating perspective
for exploring outsiders' views of Islamic Culture.
Terror & Society in Bergman's Films
Jules Zentner; Scandinavian
Drawing on two films by Ingmar Bergman about terror, questions will be asked about the origins of terror in Society
and, in particular, within male/female relationships. Possible reduction in the threat of terror will be explored.
|